Unless you have had zero access to American television or the newspaper this week, then you are probably aware of the broohaha regarding the Vanity Fair article featuring Miley Cyrus, of Disney's Hannah Montana, in nothing but a bed sheet. She is 15 years old and she is naked. Her hair is tousled, her lipstick smudged, her blue eyes bright. She is ever the image of a Disney princess de-flowered. You can't see any of her parts, but you don't really need to, now do you?
There has been a great deal of controversy regarding this picture, some have claimed it to be "art," others have called it child exploitation.
Famed celebrity photographer Annie Leibovitz took the photograph. Some say she manipulated the situation, others say everyone knew exactly what was going on. Leibovitz has always been known for her social satire, and whatever happened, this picture certainly succeeds in the satire department, the bloom is off the proverbial rose.
Regardless of the statement they were trying to make, the result is a child being exploited. Let us not forget that for how intelligent, for how well-spoken, for how accomplished Miley seems, she is only 15 years old; she is still a very young girl.
As the mother to a girl, I think I can safely say there is no way I would ever stand in a room and allow a photographer, I don't care how famous, to take a picture of my daughter in nothing but a bed sheet. There is NO WAY. I doubt I would want her to be posing for anything more than a school picture, but that is another issue all together.
When she has graduated, is an adult and on her own, she can do what she wants. I will (of course) discourage her from posing nude for photographers altogether, but she will be an adult and she will be capable to make decisions for herself. But while she is still a child, I will make the decisions for her and for her well-being.
Not only will she be far too young to understand the implications of such actions, but there is no reason that a young child should be posing. The dangers of such an action are unfathomable.
Elizabeth Soutter Schwarzer, mother, author, blogger and contributing writer for parenting.com has written an excellent piece on this very subject, I encourage you to read it.
She most eloquently explains the entire issue and speaks for all mothers by saying:
"But don't worry, Ms. Leibovitz isn't going to be blamed for corrupting the morals of two more young girls. Because protecting their sexuality, ensuring that they are clear about their own boundaries and that no one ever makes a sexual choice for them -- that's my job.
So if the question should come up and I am asked by my daughters why Hannah Montana took a picture with her clothes off, clutching her private parts, I will be honest:
She took her clothes off because an adult told her to. And no adult has the right to tell a child to take her clothes off or touch her private parts.
Because it's wrong"
-Elizabeth Soutter Schwarzer
I couldn't have said it any better myself.
Like a waterfall in slow motion, Part One
3 years ago































